TL;DR
Get home appliances delivered free with Prime
- Fast, free delivery on millions of items
- Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
- Member-only deals all year
Apple and Amazon have introduced new smart displays designed to serve as shared household hubs: the $299 HomeView and $499.99 Echo Show 16. A hands-on report says both address long-standing limits in hardware and shared use, but their different approaches—and their real-world performance—remain to be tested.
Apple and Amazon have launched new smart displays that could make a shared household screen more useful: Apple’s $299 HomeView and Amazon’s $499.99 Echo Show 16. In a brief hands-on report for The Verge, the writer said both devices appear to address weaknesses that have limited smart displays, though full testing is still needed before their everyday usefulness is clear.
The devices bring more capable hardware to a category that has often relied on underpowered screens and limited software. HomeView uses Apple’s A18 chip, also used in the MacBook Neo, and a Liquid Retina display. The Echo Show 16 has a MediaTek processor and the Nanomatte display used in Amazon’s new Alexa Tablet. The Verge report describes the hardware as a significant change from earlier smart displays, but does not establish how the products perform over extended use.
The proposed role is not to replace a laptop for homework or bills. Instead, these are shared household screens for checking calendars, managing meal plans, viewing a door camera and controlling connected devices such as lights or thermostats. Amazon’s device is presented with a more tablet-style interface and household options, including calendar and smart-home dashboards; its new Family Management home screen includes a meal-planning feature.
The companies take different approaches to who the screen serves. Amazon says its Echo Show 16 can be set up without a phone, while a phone can help. HomeView is more closely connected to an iPhone, and the report says some features rely on the phone or on recognizing its owner. In an Apple demonstration, Siri used information from text messages to anticipate a friend’s arrival and prepare a coffee machine. That was a demo, not an independently verified account of routine performance.
A central screen could make household information and connected-home controls available to everyone at home, rather than leaving calendars, shopping lists and plans scattered across one person’s phone. The Verge report frames this as a response to the growing load of coordinating family schedules and smart-home devices. It also points to the popularity of products such as the Skylight Calendar as evidence of demand for a communal household display.
The devices’ design choices matter because a shared screen is useful only if people can access it easily. The report says both are intended to remain always on and ready to tap, without requiring a PIN or dismissing a screensaver first. Amazon’s setup is aimed at the household as a whole, while Apple’s relies more on personal identity and an iPhone. Those differences may shape who can use each display and how much household information is available without a personal device.
There is a substantial price trade-off. The report compares the new models with 2023 devices priced at $85 for the Echo Show 5 and $99 for the Nest Hub. HomeView costs about three times as much as those older products, and Echo Show 16 costs more still. More capable hardware and software could make the higher prices easier to justify, but the hands-on account does not show whether families will find the added features worth the cost.
Products Worth Considering
TCL QM64L 85-Inch QD-Mini LED 4K Smart Fire TV
Sony BRAVIA 5 85-Inch Mini LED 4K HDR Smart TV (K-85XR50)
Philips Hue Festavia 130-Foot Indoor/Outdoor Smart String Lights, 500 LEDs
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Why Earlier Smart Displays Fell Short
The Verge writer says that three years earlier they had written an obituary for the smart-display category, arguing that available products tried to do too much while delivering too little well. The new models are presented as a response to that problem: stronger components, shared-use features and a clearer household role, rather than simply screens attached to smart speakers.
A tablet might seem like a straightforward alternative, but the report identifies two practical drawbacks: limited multiuser support and the risk that a portable device will be taken away from its communal spot and run out of battery. The writer cites personal experience with Google’s Pixel Tablet, whose detachable display and limited smart-home support did not work well in their home. The report also says Google reportedly canceled a successor about 18 months later; it does not provide further detail on that decision.
Apple and Amazon are trying to solve the shared-screen problem from different directions. HomeView extends Apple’s iPhone-centered ecosystem, while Echo Show 16 is designed to operate as a household device without requiring a phone. Amazon also highlights Omnisense, which the source says can sense presence, temperature and room acoustics. In one demonstration, a person approaching a driveway appeared on a home map, with a tap opening a live view from a Ring camera.
“These could finally turn the smart display into what it should have been all along: the family computer.”
— The Verge writer, describing the devices’ potential
Everyday Performance Still Untested
The report is an early hands-on assessment, not a full review. It does not establish long-term reliability, speed or ease of use, or whether household members can consistently share the devices without friction. It is also unclear how well the displays handle daily tasks such as updating a family calendar, coordinating meal plans and controlling smart-home devices across different users.
Some features described by Apple and Amazon appeared in demonstrations, and the source does not independently verify how they work outside those settings. The extent to which HomeView’s more personal features work without a nearby iPhone, and how its shared features compare with Amazon’s household-first setup, remain open questions. The report also does not detail availability dates, regional access or any additional costs associated with services and connected devices.
Full Reviews Will Test the Promise
The next step is extended testing in real homes. The Verge writer says more testing is needed to establish whether the devices’ hardware and software solve the problems identified in earlier smart displays. Useful comparisons will include how quickly household members can reach shared tools, how well the devices recognize or accommodate different users, and whether smart-home controls work reliably.
Buyers will also need to weigh the listed prices against their own needs: $299 for HomeView and $499.99 for Echo Show 16. Further reporting or product reviews may clarify how the two systems handle everyday routines, what features depend on a phone or other devices, and whether either display delivers enough practical value to justify its cost.
Key Questions
What are Apple HomeView and Amazon Echo Show 16?
They are new smart displays designed to serve as shared household screens for information such as calendars and meal plans, as well as smart-home controls. The report does not describe them as replacements for computers used for schoolwork or bills.
How much do the two displays cost?
The reported prices are $299 for Apple HomeView and $499.99 for Amazon Echo Show 16.
Do they work the same way?
No. The report describes Echo Show 16 as a household-focused device that can be set up without a phone, while HomeView is more closely tied to the iPhone and personal features. Their actual performance in daily use has not yet been established.
Have the devices been fully reviewed?
No. The source is based on brief hands-on time. The writer says proper testing is still needed to determine whether the displays work well as shared household hubs.
Source: theverge.com
